Comic Book Urban Legends Minutiae
Two fairly quick points...
1. Recently, I've been hearing some doubt on the veracity of the Steve Ditko cutting board story (Urban Legends Revealed #17). Now, I am all for getting to the truth of the matter, so if someone can verify that Greg Theakston just flat-out lied for whatever reason, then I will gladly change the status from true to false. Heck, I'd enjoy doing it, as it'd give me an easy entry for a future Urban Legends Revealed...hehe. So, please, if someone can give me something that trumps an "on the record" first hand account (and that includes someone showing me that Theakston was lying), I will gladly use it.
2. Someone asked me about this the other day, and I figured it was interesting enough to pose it to y'all. Would you like me to feature "Undetermined" Urban Legends as well? I think literally about half of Snopes' Urban Legend features end up as "Undetermined." So would you like me to do more of those types of Urban Legends? I have plenty of "undetermined" ones lying around that I do not think I have enough to make a good faith claim of true or false, so if people would like me to use them, I don't have any real problem with using them. Personally, I think it sorta defeats the purpose of the feature, but I guess I can see how it might be useful if someone responds to the "undetermined" ones with proof one way or the other. So, since I don't have a strong feeling either way, I'm opening it up to you folks.
1. Recently, I've been hearing some doubt on the veracity of the Steve Ditko cutting board story (Urban Legends Revealed #17). Now, I am all for getting to the truth of the matter, so if someone can verify that Greg Theakston just flat-out lied for whatever reason, then I will gladly change the status from true to false. Heck, I'd enjoy doing it, as it'd give me an easy entry for a future Urban Legends Revealed...hehe. So, please, if someone can give me something that trumps an "on the record" first hand account (and that includes someone showing me that Theakston was lying), I will gladly use it.
2. Someone asked me about this the other day, and I figured it was interesting enough to pose it to y'all. Would you like me to feature "Undetermined" Urban Legends as well? I think literally about half of Snopes' Urban Legend features end up as "Undetermined." So would you like me to do more of those types of Urban Legends? I have plenty of "undetermined" ones lying around that I do not think I have enough to make a good faith claim of true or false, so if people would like me to use them, I don't have any real problem with using them. Personally, I think it sorta defeats the purpose of the feature, but I guess I can see how it might be useful if someone responds to the "undetermined" ones with proof one way or the other. So, since I don't have a strong feeling either way, I'm opening it up to you folks.
posted by Brian Cronin at 5/24/2006 12:35:00 PM
39 Comments:
While I wouldn't want to see a high ratio of "undetermined" Urban Legends, it might be useful to to them up. It might lead to someone coming forth with information or a lead that might help to clear things up.
I agree. An occasional interesting "undetermined" UL would just fine.
in favor.
If you gave "undetermined" legends equal coverage, then yes I'd agree with you that it takes away from the point of the article. If you occasionally sprinkled one in? I think that could be a treat.
an undetermined bumber bonus special?
I'm all for as many of these as you want to do--false, true, undetermined, what have you. This is a terrifically fun gig.
I love love the undetermined. I like hering about Legends that I did not know existed. I have a question for you. Has Arnold Drake ever said if he had a plan to get Doom Patrol out of their death?
I wouldn't mind the occasional "undetermined" that could never be proven / disproven with information available today. I also wouldn't mind an occasional "undetermined" that was a call to arms to the community for more information.
However I'd rather see True / False determinations. Mostly because the Urban Legends you've come up with I've never heard of, and I'd hate for you to bring up something that wasn't bothering me, only to leave it unresolved.
Maybe the undetermineds could go in a separate series, "Unsolved Comic Mysteries"
One plus to doing unresolved legends is that some of the readers may have access or memory of info that can help you find out the truth once and for all. I agree it shouldn't be overdone, but you might actually find some answers to whether they're true.
One in three unconfirmed wouldn't be bad.
I think it'd be cool to do a couple of special editions of Undetermined stuff. Half the fun of these for me is just getting to hear all the industry folklore and wacky rumors.
I think a special edition featuring undetermined urban legends would be cool.
Throw out some cool points for anyone who can solve them and BAM!, you've got a column and a game.
Either way, I'd like to see some, like Dan, I just get a kick out of reading about the rumours out there.
-Ben.
I'm for the whole unresolved legends thing. Either go with a couple of special editions about these or just add one of them on to the end of each of the usual Urban Legends posts. That way you'd have 3 true or false legends and one unresolved one (per entry).
I like hering about Legends that I did not know existed.
...
Mostly because the Urban Legends you've come up with I've never heard of,
Hmm, you know I always thought the thing with urban legends was that people had heard of them and that they were well known. Coming up with a story that no one, or very few people, knew existed doesn't really make it an urban legend.
Ah well. Nevermind. Carry on...
I'm for including the "Undetermined" urban legends, as long as they don't really take over from the ones that can be demonstrably proven true or false. I also agree with the majority that it'd be better to lean towards the ones that can no longer be confirmed or proven false, or towards ones that have a notable body of conflicting evidence, over the "fishing expeditions." I believe that's the way Snopes normally does their UL posts as well.
I would love to read some undetermined urban legends.
would love to see some undetermineds, though like others, I'd recommend they become their own special installments in the ongoing series, and not just part of the regular columns. great stuff all round, by the way.
Yeah, Dan's "special edition" idea is probably the best way to go.
Some good ideas out there, folks!
Here's a vote for Jon H.'s "Unsolved Comic Mysteries," but only every now and then, not too often at all.
Even though these responses are overwhelmingly positive, they seem to boil down to "a special once in awhile" or "1 undetermined plus 3 regular ones". I'm starting to think people are just being nice because they love the usual segment so much. "I Really love this idea! But how about in tiny bits?"
Go with the occasional undetermined, simply because it may inspire some other piece of information to come your way that could confrim or deny it.
Hey, Theakston here. The story about Ditko is true. Email me at teasemag@mindspring.com for the details.
Regards,
GT
220-601
220-602
220-701
220-702
310-065
310-200
310-202
312-50
350-001
350-001-Lab
350-018
350-029
350-030
350-030-LAB
350-040
640-553
640-721
640-802
640-816
640-822
640-863
642-062
642-067
642-072
642-105
642-145
642-164
642-357
642-359
642-373
642-383
642-415
642-426
642-436
642-446
642-456
642-481
642-504
642-515
642-524
642-533
642-566
642-591
642-611
This info is much more valuable than assuming revenue expertise according to previous market come across .
---
five nights at freddy's demo | five nights at freddy's | fnaf 3
Great post. i like it. feeling great when reading your post .
----
five nights at freddy's download | five nights at freddy's game | fnaf3
Thank you so much for this information .
fitflops
nike air max 2016
pandora jewelry
burberry scarf
basketball shoes
jordan retro
true religion uk
vibram fivefingers
longchamp le pliage
longchamp bags
converse trainers
nike outlet
nike trainers
ray ban sunglasses outlet
hugo boss suits
oakley sunglasses
gucci shoes
kate spade sale
valentino outlet
green bay packers jerseys
Thank you for such a sweet tutorial - all this time later, I've found it and love the end result. I appreciate the time you spent sharing your skills.
www.happywheelsy8.com
I was very impressed by this post, this site has always been pleasant news. Thank you very much for such an interesting post. Keep working, great job! In my free time, I like play game: imgtaram. What about you?
very very nice and amazing article thanks a lot so plz keep it up https://www.urdupoetrywale.com
Thanks for sharing such wonderful stories that made us wow.
aunty
This post is absolutely brilliant! Thank you so much for sharing. 사설토토
Thanks for the great article that provided this useful information. 파워볼게임
The next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesn't disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I actually thought you have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could fix if you weren't too busy looking for attention.
스포츠토토
I have learn several good stuff here. Definitely worth bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how so much effort you place to make this type of fantastic informative web site Feel free to visit my website; 바카라사이트
Seems genuine but rather regardless of whether it's actual it doesn't prevent everybody from fostering their own thoughts of excellence. Thoughts that are persuading, thoughts that are logical and thoughts that are engaging Feel free to visit my website; 바카라사이트닷컴
تركيب طارد الحمام
شركة تركيب طارد الحمام
SLOTXO เกมใหม่ปัจจุบันปี 2023 เเนะนำเกมประสิทธิภาพสูงอัพเดทใหม่ๆมีเกมส์ให้เลือกเล่นมากยิ่งกว่า 200 เกมส์ แต่ละเกมมีต้นแบบแล้วก็อัตราที่สูงเเตกแตกต่างกัน ค้ำประกันจากผู้เล่นจริง เเนวโน้มของเกม pg slot หมายถึงล้ำยุค เข้าเล่นง่ายได้เร็ว
Post a Comment
<< Home